Flat fee or percentage? Where direct delivery actually wins.
Taking delivery orders yourself saves money on some orders and loses it on others. The line between them is easy to find.
The short version
- Delivery apps usually keep 15% to 30% of each order.
- A courier you book yourself costs a flat fee, from about $7.
- At 30%, going direct wins on orders over about $23. At 15%, over about $47.
- So keep small orders on the app, and bring big orders and regulars to you.
Two ways to pay for the same ride
When an order comes through a delivery app, the app keeps a share of it. The share depends on your plan, and on the big services it runs from 15% to 30%. A $40 order on the top plan costs you $12.
When the customer orders from you directly, you can still have a courier collect it. You pay a set fee for the trip, starting around $7, and the size of the order makes no difference. That same $40 order costs you $6.99.
- Delivery app at 30%
- Delivery app at 15%
- Flat courier fee
Find your line
The two lines cross at one order size. Below it the app is cheaper. Above it, direct is. To find yours, divide the courier fee by your commission rate.
$6.99 ÷ 0.30 = $23.30
Courier fee, divided by commission rate, gives your break-even order.
| Order size | App at 30% | App at 15% | Flat fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| $18 | $5.40 | $2.70 | $6.99 |
| $40 | $12.00 | $6.00 | $6.99 |
| $110 | $33.00 | $16.50 | $6.99 |
The cheapest option in each row is shaded.
A percentage hurts on big orders. A flat fee hurts on small ones.
What the sum leaves out
The sum is honest but not complete. Four things move the line, and you should know them before you act.
- Card fees. On a direct order you pay your own card processing.
- Your own offer. If you give 10% off to bring people direct, that comes out of the saving.
- Distance. Courier fees rise with the length of the trip and vary by city.
- New faces. The app finds customers you would never have met. That is worth paying for.
What to do with this
Do not leave the apps. Use them for what they are good at, which is strangers. Then give the people who already like you an easy way back: a card in the bag, a text thread, a page of your own.
Start with your biggest orders. Catering trays and office boxes sit far above the line, and they are the easiest customers to ask.
Run your own numbers.
Pick your order size and your plan, and see which side of the line you are on.
Questions people ask
Is direct delivery always cheaper than a delivery app?
No. On small orders a flat courier fee can cost more than the app’s percentage. Direct wins once the order is larger than the courier fee divided by your commission rate.
Should I stop using delivery apps?
Usually not. They bring new customers. The saving comes from moving repeat and large orders to your own channel.
What about pickup orders?
Pickup has no courier fee at all, so a direct pickup order avoids both costs.
Figures: commission plans and per-delivery courier pricing as published on DoorDash’s merchant pages, checked [DATE CHECKED]. Rates differ by service, city and contract, so check your own.


